This article delves into the key legal aspects related to the criminal liability of street racing, particularly focusing on Section 315d of the German Criminal Code (StGB), intent to kill, and the confiscation of vehicles.
1. Prohibited Motor Vehicle Races (§ 315d StGB)
Legal Elements
Section 315d StGB criminalizes illegal street racing. The statute covers three main variants:
- Organization or Conduct of a Race: This includes both actively organizing and conducting such races.
- Participation as a Driver: This pertains to the participation of the driver in the race, regardless of their involvement in organizing it.
- Solo Racing: A driver can be criminally liable even without other participants if they drive at an inappropriate speed, behave in a grossly unlawful and reckless manner, aiming to achieve the highest possible speed.
Penalties
Penalties range up to two years’ imprisonment or a fine. If another person’s safety is endangered, the penalty increases to up to five years’ imprisonment.
Vehicle Confiscation
The confiscation of the vehicle according to § 315f StGB is a severe consequence. A vehicle can be confiscated not only after the completion of legal proceedings but also immediately after the offense to secure the confiscation. Issues arise when the prosecution considers an early sale of the seized vehicle.
2. Intent to Kill in Street Racing
Conditional Intent to Kill
Conditional intent to kill is present when the perpetrator recognizes the potential for fatal outcomes and at least accepts it as a possibility. This is particularly relevant in highly risky racing situations where participants consciously accept the risk of a fatal accident. The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) has emphasized that determining conditional intent to kill requires a thorough assessment of the objective and subjective circumstances, including the perpetrator’s psychological state.
3. Confiscation of Vehicles in Street Racing
Legal Framework and Practical Implementation
Under § 315f StGB, vehicles used in prohibited street races can be confiscated. This includes vehicles owned by third parties if the owner was aware of the possible use of the vehicle for racing purposes. Challenges arise with leased vehicles, where courts have shown restraint when the owner was not directly involved in the crime or when there were no indications of endangering legal interests.
Defense Strategies
A successful defense might argue that the legislator primarily targeted stereotypical street racing activities rather than a one-time lapse of an otherwise law-abiding driver. This argument is particularly relevant when confiscation could have severe economic consequences for uninvolved parties, such as in the case of leased vehicles.
4. Conclusion
Illegal street racing and its criminal consequences go far beyond mere traffic offenses. Participants face significant legal risks, including potential convictions for murder in the event of fatal accidents, extensive vehicle confiscation, and permanent revocation of driving licenses. Competent and proactive defense is crucial in these cases to mitigate or avoid the far-reaching legal and economic consequences.
Our law firm specialises in criminal defence, white-collar crime and IT law / technology law. Note our activity in digital evidence in IT security and software law.
- Protecting Business Secrets in Germany: Legal Risks When Employees Forward Emails to Private Accounts - 6. October 2024
- Law Enforcement’s Access to the TOR Network: Investigative Techniques and Legal Implications - 5. October 2024
- The Challenge of Investigating and Defending Against Cryptomessenger Cases in Germany and Europe - 5. October 2024