The A1 certificate has become a focal point in discussions surrounding cross-border employment within the EU, particularly due to its implications in both legal and compliance frameworks. A recent decision by the German Federal Court of Justice (BGH) highlighted the critical role the A1 certificate plays, especially when misused in cases of illegal employment. This article explores the significance of the A1 certificate, the key points of the court ruling, and the broader implications within German employment criminal law.
The Federal Court’s Decision on the Misuse of A1 Certificates
In a recent ruling from September 2024 (Case No. 5 StR 325/24), the German Federal Court dealt with a case involving the illegal employment of non-EU nationals using forged A1 certificates. The defendants operated temporary employment agencies in Estonia, Lithuania, and Latvia, sending workers—primarily from non-EU countries like Ukraine and Moldova—to Germany. Without proper work permits or visas, the workers were presented as having valid A1 certificates, making it seem as though they were temporarily employed and legally eligible to work in Germany.
By using forged IDs and falsified A1 certificates, the defendants created the appearance of compliance with EU regulations while evading social security contributions in Germany. Over four years, the group generated €29 million in revenue, while millions of euros in social security contributions were dodged.
The court’s decision reaffirmed the seriousness of such actions, leading to convictions for human trafficking, withholding wages, and misappropriating social security contributions. The BGH also clarified that forged A1 certificates do not carry any legal weight, particularly when the identity of the workers involved is falsified.
This case underscores the severe penalties associated with using falsified A1 certificates and highlights the certificate’s importance within the broader framework of EU labor law and social security compliance.
What is the A1 Certificate?
The A1 certificate is a crucial document for employees temporarily working in another EU country. It certifies that the worker remains subject to the social security regulations of their home country while working abroad. This prevents double contributions in two countries and ensures the employee’s social security remains intact.
The European Union’s Posted Workers Directive has been updated to address the complexities of modern cross-border labor. This directive ensures that employees working abroad, even temporarily, are subject to the labor laws of the host country, including wage and social conditions. However, the A1 certificate provides an exception by confirming that the worker continues to be covered under the social security system of their home country.
Where is the A1 Certificate Required?
The A1 certificate is required for any employee traveling for work to another EU country, the European Economic Area (EEA), or Switzerland. Even short trips require this certificate, and it can be requested at any time by local authorities, such as customs officers or labor inspectors.
For instance, countries like France, Austria, and Switzerland are known for their strict enforcement of the A1 requirement. Employees and employers who fail to present an A1 certificate during inspections can face heavy fines, even for brief work stays.
How to Obtain the A1 Certificate?
The certificate must be applied for through the German Liaison Office for Health Insurance Abroad (DVKA). The application process is electronic, and companies should allow a few days for processing. Due to privacy concerns, the certificate is usually sent via postal mail.
It is essential to apply for a new A1 certificate for every trip abroad. While it may seem possible to submit the certificate after traveling, in practice, many countries do not accept this. Nations such as France and Austria have implemented regulations that explicitly reject the retroactive submission of A1 certificates.
The Role of the A1 Certificate in Employment Law and Criminal Law in Germany
The significance of the A1 certificate extends beyond mere compliance. In Germany, employment criminal law (Arbeitsstrafrecht) places a strong emphasis on the proper documentation of workers’ social security status, particularly in cross-border employment. The failure to provide proper A1 certificates, or worse, the use of forged certificates, can result in serious legal consequences.
In the recent BGH ruling, the court not only focused on the fraudulent use of A1 certificates but also highlighted the implications for employers who engage in illegal employment practices. In this case, the workers were from non-EU countries, and the employers tried to evade German social security contributions by using false documentation. This led to convictions under sections of the German Penal Code that deal with wage withholding (Section 266a StGB) and illegal employment.
The case illustrates the crucial role the A1 certificate plays in ensuring compliance with social security laws. It also reflects the potential for misuse in complex schemes aimed at evading these obligations, as seen in the BGH case. The court made it clear that any A1 certificate based on falsified information does not hold legal validity and cannot shield employers from liability.
Conclusion: The Importance of Compliance
The A1 certificate is a vital document for any company or employee engaged in cross-border work within the EU. Its importance extends beyond simple bureaucratic procedure; it plays a key role in ensuring that workers are properly covered by social security systems and that companies comply with both domestic and European labor laws.
The recent BGH decision serves as a strong reminder of the severe legal consequences of misusing the A1 certificate, particularly in cases of illegal employment. For companies, ensuring proper compliance with A1 requirements is not just a matter of avoiding fines—it is about adhering to broader principles of labor law, fairness, and legal responsibility.
For employers sending workers abroad, it is crucial to remain vigilant in securing and presenting valid A1 certificates. As labor markets continue to globalize, the intersection of employment law, social security compliance, and criminal law will only grow more significant, and the A1 certificate will remain a central document in navigating these legal complexities.
Our law firm specialises in criminal defence, white-collar crime and IT law / technology law. Note our activity in digital evidence in IT security and software law.