The Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) is poised to significantly expand sustainability reporting requirements for companies across Europe, including Germany. As Germany moves towards implementing this EU directive into national law, many businesses will be affected, facing additional obligations in their corporate reporting. Here, we break down what the CSRD is, its key components, and how Germany is preparing for its introduction.
What is the CSRD?
The CSRD builds upon the Non-Financial Reporting Directive (NFRD) and will require a much larger scope of companies to engage in sustainability reporting. In contrast to previous regulations, the CSRD mandates that not only large corporations but also many medium-sized enterprises and small publicly listed companies will be required to report on their sustainability performance. This marks a significant shift in the landscape of corporate responsibility, particularly in the areas of environmental, social, and governance (ESG) issues.
Crucially, the CSRD goes beyond requiring companies to report only on their internal activities. Under the new directive, companies must also provide information on their entire value chain, extending their reporting obligations to include suppliers and other partners.
Who is Affected?
The CSRD applies to a broad range of companies, including:
- Large companies that meet at least two of the following criteria: more than 250 employees, over 40 million euros in revenue, or a balance sheet total exceeding 20 million euros.
- Listed small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) that were previously exempt from many reporting requirements.
- Subsidiaries of large corporations, which will be included in the consolidated reports of their parent companies.
What are the Key Reporting Obligations?
The CSRD will introduce several significant changes in sustainability reporting:
- Broader Reporting Scope: Companies must detail how their strategies align with global climate goals, such as the Paris Agreement. Social issues and corporate governance will also need to be addressed comprehensively.
- Third-Party Audits and Standardized Formats: The reports must be audited by external parties and published in a standardized electronic format, ensuring transparency and comparability.
- Integration into Financial Reports: Sustainability reports will no longer be separate documents but must be integrated into the company’s management report, providing a clearer link between sustainability and financial performance.
Germany’s Implementation Process
Germany is well on its way to transposing the CSRD into national law. The federal government has presented a draft that aims to closely follow the EU’s requirements. This is a substantial undertaking, and the country is racing to implement the necessary legal framework in time to meet the EU deadlines.
On September 27, 2024, the German Bundesrat (Federal Council) reviewed the government’s draft and issued extensive comments on the proposed legislation. While the Bundesrat supports the CSRD’s general objectives, it also raised concerns about the significant administrative burdens that companies will face.
Challenges for Businesses
- Increased Bureaucratic Burden: The CSRD’s requirements for extensive data collection, reporting, and auditing will place a heavy administrative load on many companies, particularly small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). Many SMEs will also face indirect impacts as they will need to provide sustainability data to larger companies with which they work.
- Workforce Shortages: The Bundesrat highlighted the current shortage of qualified personnel to handle sustainability reporting. Companies will need to dedicate resources and train employees to meet the CSRD’s demands, potentially diverting focus from other essential projects.
- Duplication of Reporting Obligations: There is a risk of overlap with existing national and EU reporting regulations, such as Germany’s Supply Chain Due Diligence Act (LkSG). The Bundesrat has called for efforts to harmonize reporting requirements to avoid unnecessary duplication.
Support for SMEs
The Bundesrat also expressed concerns about the pressure the CSRD places on SMEs. Although many SMEs are not directly required to report under the CSRD, they will still need to provide data to their larger business partners. To alleviate this burden, the Bundesrat has proposed a “Value-Chain Reporting Cap” that would allow SMEs to provide estimates or summary data instead of detailed information.
Recommendations for Businesses
For companies impacted by the CSRD, now is the time to start preparing. Key steps include:
- Assessment of Current Reporting Systems: Companies should evaluate their existing reporting frameworks and adapt them to the new requirements under the CSRD.
- Sustainability Strategy: Aligning business strategies with ESG goals will be critical for long-term competitiveness under the CSRD framework.
- Employee Training: Staff must be trained to understand the new reporting standards and how to integrate them into daily business practices.
- Invest in IT Solutions: Digital tools for data collection and analysis will be essential for companies to monitor their entire value chain effectively.
Conclusion
While the CSRD presents significant challenges, particularly in terms of administrative load and workforce demands, it also offers opportunities. Companies that excel in transparent sustainability reporting will benefit from increased credibility with investors, customers, and other stakeholders who are increasingly prioritizing ESG factors.
Germany’s implementation of the CSRD marks a turning point for corporate sustainability in Europe. By preparing early, businesses can not only ensure compliance but also position themselves as leaders in responsible corporate governance and environmental stewardship.
Our law firm specialises in criminal defence, white-collar crime and IT law / technology law. Note our activity in digital evidence in IT security and software law.